Erin Yurday
Author
The concept of "good" and "bad" debt is a commonly used framework in personal finance education. It refers to a broad distinction between borrowing that may improve someone's financial position over time, and borrowing that tends to cost more than it delivers. These are generalisations rather than rules — whether any borrowing is appropriate depends entirely on individual circumstances.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute financial advice. Always make sure you can afford repayments before taking on any borrowing. ClearScore is a credit broker, not a lender.
Some forms of borrowing are commonly associated with long-term financial benefit, because they may be linked to assets that hold or grow in value, or to increased earning potential over time. Examples often cited in this context include:
Mortgages — a mortgage is a loan secured against a property. Because property is often considered a long-term asset, mortgages are frequently described as "good debt." However, property values can fall as well as rise, and the suitability of a mortgage depends heavily on individual financial circumstances, including income, existing commitments and long-term plans. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.
Student loans — government student loans in England are sometimes characterised as an investment in future earning potential. According to the Department for Education, graduates earn on average £11,500 more per year than non-graduates. That said, whether a student loan represents good value depends on the course, career path and individual repayment circumstances.
Business borrowing — borrowing to fund a business venture is sometimes cited as potentially productive debt, as it may generate income. Whether this is the case depends on the viability of the business and the terms of the borrowing.
These examples share some common characteristics: they tend to involve lower interest rates than consumer credit, a structured repayment plan, and a connection to something that may retain or generate value. None of this means they are automatically suitable for any individual.
Other forms of borrowing are commonly associated with high costs and no lasting financial benefit. Examples often cited include:
High-interest credit cards — carrying a balance on a standard credit card is expensive. The average credit card interest rate in the UK reached 24.66% in January 2026, the highest for over 30 years, according to Bank of England data. Balances left unpaid can grow quickly at these rates.
Payday loans — short-term, high-cost credit products can carry APRs running into the hundreds or thousands of percent. They are often associated with cycles of repeat borrowing and escalating costs.
Credit used for depreciating purchases — using credit to fund items that lose value quickly, such as holidays, electronics or clothing, means paying interest on something that generates no financial return. This is often cited as a less financially efficient use of borrowing.
These forms of borrowing share characteristics including high interest rates, no connection to an asset or income source, and the potential for repayment difficulties if income changes.
Average UK household debt (excluding mortgages) stood at approximately £18,392 heading into 2026, according to NimbleFins analysis of Bank of England and ONS data. This includes credit cards, personal loans, overdrafts and other unsecured borrowing. Households with mortgages held an average of around £197,811 in mortgage debt in 2025.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.
Rather than setting out rules for when to borrow, it may be useful to note the factors people commonly weigh when assessing whether borrowing makes sense in their situation:
On the side of borrowing: whether the purpose is linked to something that may grow in value or generate income; whether the interest rate is affordable and fixed; whether there is a clear, realistic plan for repayment; and whether the terms are flexible enough to accommodate changes in circumstances.
On the side of paying down existing debt: whether the interest rate on existing borrowing is high; whether repayments are limiting the ability to build an emergency fund or save; and whether the debt is tied to anything of lasting value.
These are considerations, not recommendations. What is appropriate depends entirely on individual financial circumstances.
If you are struggling with debt or repayments, free, impartial support is available from StepChange, National Debtline and Citizens Advice.
The concepts discussed in this article reflect general financial education and do not constitute advice for any individual. Every situation is different. Always make sure you can afford repayments before taking on any borrowing.
Read more:
The concept of "good" and "bad" debt is a commonly used framework in personal finance education. It refers to a broad distinction between borrowing that may improve someone's financial position over time, and borrowing that tends to cost more than it delivers. These are generalisations rather than rules — whether any borrowing is appropriate depends entirely on individual circumstances.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute financial advice. Always make sure you can afford repayments before taking on any borrowing. ClearScore is a credit broker, not a lender.
Some forms of borrowing are commonly associated with long-term financial benefit, because they may be linked to assets that hold or grow in value, or to increased earning potential over time. Examples often cited in this context include:
Mortgages — a mortgage is a loan secured against a property. Because property is often considered a long-term asset, mortgages are frequently described as "good debt." However, property values can fall as well as rise, and the suitability of a mortgage depends heavily on individual financial circumstances, including income, existing commitments and long-term plans. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.
Student loans — government student loans in England are sometimes characterised as an investment in future earning potential. According to the Department for Education, graduates earn on average £11,500 more per year than non-graduates. That said, whether a student loan represents good value depends on the course, career path and individual repayment circumstances.
Business borrowing — borrowing to fund a business venture is sometimes cited as potentially productive debt, as it may generate income. Whether this is the case depends on the viability of the business and the terms of the borrowing.
These examples share some common characteristics: they tend to involve lower interest rates than consumer credit, a structured repayment plan, and a connection to something that may retain or generate value. None of this means they are automatically suitable for any individual.
Other forms of borrowing are commonly associated with high costs and no lasting financial benefit. Examples often cited include:
High-interest credit cards — carrying a balance on a standard credit card is expensive. The average credit card interest rate in the UK reached 24.66% in January 2026, the highest for over 30 years, according to Bank of England data. Balances left unpaid can grow quickly at these rates.
Payday loans — short-term, high-cost credit products can carry APRs running into the hundreds or thousands of percent. They are often associated with cycles of repeat borrowing and escalating costs.
Credit used for depreciating purchases — using credit to fund items that lose value quickly, such as holidays, electronics or clothing, means paying interest on something that generates no financial return. This is often cited as a less financially efficient use of borrowing.
These forms of borrowing share characteristics including high interest rates, no connection to an asset or income source, and the potential for repayment difficulties if income changes.
Average UK household debt (excluding mortgages) stood at approximately £18,392 heading into 2026, according to NimbleFins analysis of Bank of England and ONS data. This includes credit cards, personal loans, overdrafts and other unsecured borrowing. Households with mortgages held an average of around £197,811 in mortgage debt in 2025.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.
Rather than setting out rules for when to borrow, it may be useful to note the factors people commonly weigh when assessing whether borrowing makes sense in their situation:
On the side of borrowing: whether the purpose is linked to something that may grow in value or generate income; whether the interest rate is affordable and fixed; whether there is a clear, realistic plan for repayment; and whether the terms are flexible enough to accommodate changes in circumstances.
On the side of paying down existing debt: whether the interest rate on existing borrowing is high; whether repayments are limiting the ability to build an emergency fund or save; and whether the debt is tied to anything of lasting value.
These are considerations, not recommendations. What is appropriate depends entirely on individual financial circumstances.
If you are struggling with debt or repayments, free, impartial support is available from StepChange, National Debtline and Citizens Advice.
The concepts discussed in this article reflect general financial education and do not constitute advice for any individual. Every situation is different. Always make sure you can afford repayments before taking on any borrowing.
Read more: